What Makes a Good Leader (Elon Musk Notwithstanding).

5 min read

What Makes a Good Leader (Elon Musk Notwithstanding)

Great leaders are charismatic. They hold strong opinions. They take strong stands. Through force of personality alone, they tend to own the rooms they inhabit. Like Jeff Bezos. Or Mark Cuban. Or Elon Musk, who once said, "I say something, and then it usually happens. Maybe not on schedule, but it usually happens."

In short, great leaders are extremely confident -- and that confidence produces results.

But not always.

According to a 2012 study published in the Academy of Management Journal, humble leaders are not only more likable but also more effective. But what is a "humble" leader?

According to the researchers:

We uncover that leader humility involves leaders modeling to followers how to grow and produce positive organizational outcomes by leading followers to believe that their own developmental journeys and feelings of uncertainty are legitimate in the workplace.

... the emergent humility-in-leadership model informs a broad range of leadership issues, including organizational development and change, the evolution of leader-follower relationships, new pathways for engaging followers, and the integration of top-down and bottom-up organizing.

Or in non-researcher-speak, humble leaders are relatable, approachable, empathetic, and — especially if you’re a fan of servant leadership — more helpful.

For example, a 2011 study found that humble people were more than twice as likely to give more of their time to those in need than those who were not. (Since even cocky people like to think they’re humble, those who self-reported as “not humble” must have been really full of themselves.)

SEE: Release Planning and Honest Bidding

(And before you ask, I tested low on humility on Ray Dalio’s Principles You personality assessment. But I came out high on practicality, composure, and flexibility, so I got that going for me, which is nice.)

Long digression aside, leaders who help employees in need — who need additional training, or mentoring, or help making connections, or simply a second chance — tend to produce better outcomes because they help average employees to become better employees, and good employees to become great employees.

In short, they see the need and, therefore, take the time to develop the people they work with.

Because they realize that no one ever does anything worthwhile on their own.

But wait, there’s more:

  • Research links humility with seeking self-improvement; what leader doesn’t benefit from constant learning and growth?

  • Research links humility with a greater ability to maintain self-esteem in the face of adversity or failure; what leader doesn’t benefit from staying positive and upbeat in the middle of a crisis?

  • Research links humility with the ability to develop stronger social bonds; what leader doesn’t benefit from building stronger professional relationships?

And then there’s this. A 2011 study published in Personality and Individual

Differences found that humility was a “unique predictor” of job performance. Humble people don’t just make better bosses. They also make better employees.

Which means they’re more likely to be accepted as leaders by their teams. A 2020 study published in the Journal of Business and Psychology found that virtual teams want their leaders to be “doers”–people great at planning. Prioritizing. Staying on task. Helping others stay on task.

Bottom line? Outgoing, charismatic, confident people tend to be seen as leaders.

But seeming like a leader doesn’t make someone a leader, especially in the eyes of the people whom they lead. What really matters are results. Given the choice, your employees want a leader who is relatable. Approachable. Empathetic. They are willing to admit their own flaws and weaknesses. Willing to work to overcome their own flaws and weaknesses. Willing to help others do the same.

People who want to get things done and know they can’t do it alone.

In short, a humble leader.

Which may or may not be you. (Evidently, it’s not me, according to at least one personality assessment.)

But it should be the people you hire to supervise and manage your employees.

Science says so.

Jeff Haden

Find out what a connected system would change in your business.

In a no-risk discovery we look at how your work moves between your systems today and show what one connected system would do differently. You pay only if you proceed. Or see how we approach it.

Book the no-risk discovery

More on the same problem:

Frequently asked questions.

What does humility look like in a leader day to day?

Asking for input before deciding and changing the decision when the input is better. Saying what they do not know. Giving credit by name and taking responsibility for the team's misses. Spending time on the people who are struggling rather than only the stars. Treating a mistake as information. None of this is softness; humble leaders in the research still set direction and hold standards. They simply do not need to be the smartest person in the room.

Can a confident, charismatic person also be a humble leader?

Yes. The research contrasts humility with arrogance, not with confidence. A leader can hold strong opinions, take clear stands and own a room while still believing that other people's development and uncertainty are legitimate, and while being willing to be wrong in public. The combination is rarer than either trait alone, which is why charisma gets noticed and humility gets results.

How do you hire or promote for the traits of a good leader?

Ask candidates to describe a decision they got wrong and what they changed, and listen for whether anyone else appears in the story. Ask references who the candidate developed and where those people are now. Look at the retention and growth of teams they have led rather than at their personal output. Interview performance rewards confidence; the people who worked for the candidate know whether the confidence came with humility.

Why do humble leaders get better results from their teams?

Because they make it safe to say something is wrong early, which is when it is cheap to fix. Because they develop average performers into good ones instead of relying on a few stars. And because people who feel their own growth is legitimate stay longer and try harder. The studies cited on this page connect humility with better job performance, stronger relationships and resilience under failure, each of which shows up in team outcomes.

Can humility be learned as a leadership skill?

To a useful degree. Practices that build it include asking one more question before answering, naming the person whose idea you are using, running a short retrospective after every significant decision, and inviting someone on the team to tell you when you are wrong. Personality assessments can tell a leader where they start. What changes outcomes is the behavior the team sees, and behavior can be practiced.

Where we're not the right answer

We'll tell you if we're a fit. If we're not, we'll tell you that too.

  • Your current stack works and nobody wants to change it
  • You want licences resold at a discount and nothing else
  • Your internal team owns the operating model and is not handing it over
  • You want hours of configuration work and nothing run for you: that is on our services pages, and it is not a managed solution
How we start

Most of our best clients come to us with a feeling, not a plan.

"Something isn't working." "We're outgrowing our tools." "We're afraid to make the wrong move." No-Risk Discovery is a short, practical conversation that gets you clarity before you commit to anything big. We'll tell you if we're a fit. If we're not, we'll tell you that too.

Talk to us

Have a question about this?

Say who you are and ask. A person replies within one business day.

A new client, or thinking about becoming one
What are you looking for?
An agentic solution (AI OS) is licensed and sold with managed services. An integrated solution is built for a professional services fee. A Service is professional work, done by the hour, the month or the project. Not sure yet is a fine answer.

Agentic solutions (AI OS)

Integrated solutions

Services

Platforms You Use or Are Considering

Your details are never shared or sold.