In House vs Outsourcing Software Development: The Real Trade-Offs.
When you decide to develop software or mobile applications for your business, you will face the question: "Should I outsource or keep it in-house?" This is what business schools call a “make vs. buy decision,” and it is something all businesses struggle with.
So what are the factors that determine which decision makes the most sense for your business?
Software development is the process of defining, conceiving, specifying, designing, programming, documenting, testing, bug fixing, and much more. It requires a high level of focus and dedication to succeed.
Do you have the resources and experience in each field? Are those resources primarily dedicated to keeping your business running, i.e., “putting out fires?” If so, it may be unrealistic to expect them to carve out time to develop a new product.
Many executives choose this option because they feel that they’d have more control over a product if it were developed in-house. However, if you’re considering this option, have you factored in all the costs and time involved in finding talented resources? Do you have the ability to screen qualified engineers from unqualified ones? Do you have the budget to recruit top talent from the FAANG (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google) companies, which pay top dollar?
Many executives underestimate the difficulty in recruiting, managing, and retaining top talent.
Maybe you’ve already developed part of your product in-house. However, it didn’t turn out exactly as you’d planned. Or perhaps you planned to complete a project in six months, but it actually took 12.
This happens all the time. Oftentimes, medium to large-sized businesses find themselves locked into routines and habits that do a good job of maintaining their core product. Yet they are inefficient at innovating.
If you: a) have team members with the following skills: product definition, project management, user experience design, user interface design, coding, testing, documenting, and systems architecture, and b) those team members have the necessary bandwidth (i.e., they’re not fully deployed on another project), then you are certainly well-positioned to develop in-house.
Sometimes the most talented people in the world can’t work together. Chemistry is important. Has your team worked together on other projects before? Were those projects successful? Do they get more productive over time? Are your employees happy, stimulated, and/or satisfied?
If the answer to these questions is yes, then consider developing in-house.
The advantage of working with an outsourcer is that they live and die by technology. They’ve dedicated their lives and careers to building new things that, to use the cliche, “make the world a better place.” The successful ones are always at the forefront of what’s new in the tech world.
Is that the case in your business? The tech landscape is continuously evolving, and it can be challenging to stay up to date. Is your team ahead of the curve? Do they love technology so much that they dedicate their free time to it?
If so, then you have the right resources to develop in-house.
Running a successful business involves countless make-vs-buy decisions. What should you outsource and what should you do internally? The rule of thumb should be to focus your in-house resources on what your strengths are and outsource everything else.
So next time you are considering a new software project, ask yourself that one question: Is your team the best choice to build it? If not, then you should be looking for an outsourcer who is.
Let us know when you make the decision.
CodeStringers
In a no-risk discovery we look at your CRM, finance and operations systems and who owns each part, and show what a connected system would do differently. You pay only if you proceed. Or see how we approach it.
More on the same problem:
Software Development Team Structure: The Roles, Models, and Right Size (article)
How to Choose a Software Development Company: A Buyer's Framework (article)
In-house cost is salary plus benefits, taxes, recruiting, equipment, management and the ramp-up period, which together run well above base salary. Outsourced work is billed at a rate that includes those overheads, and offshore rates are a fraction of US salaries. In-house is usually cheaper per hour only for a team that is fully utilized year round. For variable or project-based work, outsourcing avoids paying for idle capacity.
Losing knowledge of your own system if the vendor holds all of it. Vendors who bid low and recover through change orders. Communication gaps across time zones and cultures. Quality that is hard to check without technical staff on your side. And dependence on a vendor's stability. Each is managed by keeping ownership of the code and the architecture decisions, choosing vendors on track record, and keeping at least one technical person who can evaluate the work.
Most companies that build software do. The usual split keeps product decisions, architecture and the parts of the system that embody the company's competitive edge in house, and outsources sustained development capacity, specialist skills or non-core modules. The split works when one person owns priorities across both groups and the outsourced team is integrated into the same backlog and review process rather than handed a specification and left alone.
When the software has become the business, when the volume of work justifies a full-time team that will be busy year round, and when the company can recruit and lead engineers itself. Insourcing without the ability to hire and manage well tends to reproduce the problems that drove outsourcing in the first place. A staged transition, with the vendor training the new hires and overlapping for a period, protects the knowledge.
Ask whether your team is the best choice to build it. Do they have the skills, the bandwidth and a track record together on similar work. Is this project close to your core advantage or peripheral to it. What is the cost of delay if recruiting takes six months. If the honest answers point away from the internal team, outsource it and keep the product decisions; if they point toward the team, keep it and protect their time.
"Something isn't working." "We're outgrowing our tools." "We're afraid to make the wrong move." No-Risk Discovery is a short, practical conversation that gets you clarity before you commit to anything big. We'll tell you if we're a fit. If we're not, we'll tell you that too.
Say who you are and ask. A person replies within one business day.